
Meaningless hype. Boring games. Inane off-field shenanigans. With every meeting, it looks more and more like the Red Sox-Yankee rivalry has jumped the shark. Old Boss/New Boss is FanHouse's look at some baseball rivalry alternatives.
Old Boss: Mets vs. Braves
New Boss: Mets vs. Phillies
The day that Steve Avery plunked Jose Vizcaino in 1996 after Vizcaino thrust his arms up on the basepaths after a Met home run was the day the Mets/Braves rivalry started to take shape. The rivalry reached new heights after Chipper Jones' "put on your Yankee gear" quote towards Mets fans after the 1999 NLCS where the Braves beat the Mets in six games. Throw in John Rocker and all he stood for, and you had what might have been the nastiest rivalry in sports at that time.
But Mets/Braves has been overtaken by Mets/Phillies, probably for good. Until last season, the Mets and the Phillies have never had a chance to develop a rivalry because the teams had never, ever, been good at the same time. During the times that the Phillies have been good, the Mets have been terrible ... and during the few pockets of time that the Mets have been competitive, the Phillies have been mired in mediocrity. The Mets rivalries have always been forged out of the standings at the time.
Then came Jimmy Rollins' "we're the team to beat" quote, followed by the Mets collapse and the Phillies division title, and Mets/Phillies has been cemented this as the rivalry in this division.
But it isn't so much the players that have created this rivalry as have the fans. Phillie fans now come to Shea Stadium in numbers that match the ones that Met fans reach when they go the other way ... and fights in the stands have reached numbers that are starting approach the number of fights in the stands during Dolphins/Jets game at the Meadowlands (and that's pretty high). And considering the fact that both teams feature fan bases from the robust and "in your face" northeast corridor, don't expect that number to wane ... and don't expect this rivalry to calm down anytime soon.
Mets/Braves will always be there, if perhaps not to the point it was around the turn of the century ... especially after Chipper retires. And Mets/Marlins could be a darkhorse candidate for a nasty rivalry, especially if Hanley Ramirez feels the same way about the Mets that he did last September (and if the rest of the Marlins share his sentiment). Plus, with the amount of transplanted New Yorkers in Miami, some of that envy could spill into the stands as well.
But when it comes to drama and sizzle, nothing tops Mets/Phillies in this division.

















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-16-2008 @ 10:01AM
James I McFall said...
fact is, in philly we've never had a good rivalry, but a new york/phliiy rivalry was always just below the surface. i still remember tug mcgraw's comments in philly's only world series celebration parade. as annoying as mets fans are in philly, you gotta respect they come here, and are sometimes louder than the home team fans. there have been many connections between the 2 teams thru the mets history, namely, ashburn, mcgraw, dykrsta. good for philly, good for baseball!
Reply
4-16-2008 @ 2:48PM
Bernie said...
Nails (Lenny D.)was the man is his day I agree. The Mets/Philly make a great rivalry I'm looking forward to what we are going to see out of those games this year especially in the fall. My bet is the team that can say they have more quality starts out of their respective pitching staffs will be the top dog in the division. I don't see Atlanta or many other teams in the NL stay with these two teams. The National league west might have something to bring to the table but I don't see them winning it all the team to beat will come from these two in the NL.
Reply