
Meaningless hype. Boring games. Inane off-field shenanigans. With every meeting, it looks more and more like the Red Sox-Yankee rivalry has jumped the shark. Old Boss/New Boss is FanHouse's look at some baseball rivalry alternatives.
Old Boss: Yankees vs. Red Sox
New Boss: Yankees vs. Rays
Let's just get this out of the way right up front, nothing in the AL East will ever touch the Red Sox and Yankees for impact on the game of baseball. Other than the Giants and Dodgers, no rivalry can ever encompass so much of the game's history nor involve as many of the most important men to ever don stirrups.
But it's gotten awfully stale of late. The networks forego coverage of other games to bring us all 18 of their meetings on national television, blowhard executives of both teams fight over who has a bigger fan club and the increasingly dunderheaded machinations of the fans of both sides have taken the focus off the field. Last weekend's t-shirt nonsense is a perfect example. Every part of it, from the dope who buried the shirt to the dope who dug it up to the dopes who promulgated the existence of a curse, was perfectly stupid and a sign that there's more style than substance.
What can replace it in the American League East, though? The Orioles are a non-factor and, while the Blue Jays have a nice team, there's not much heat coming from Toronto. That leaves us with the nascent ill-will between the Yankees and Rays.
The story of how it began is familiar at this point. Elliot Johnson of the Rays plowed Yankee catcher Francisco Cervelli at the plate and touched off a rant from Joe Girardi about how you play the game in spring training. The Rays bristled at the notion that the Yankees were of a different standard and it boiled over when Shelley Duncan slid into Akinori Iwamura spikes high and touched off an old-fashioned brawl.
That's the kind of on-field fire that marked the late 90's resurgence of the Sox-Yanks feud and the kind of fire that's missing from it today. As much as the Red Sox like to complain about the Evil Empire from New York, it can be hard to see the fundamental differences between the two sides. That's not the case for the Rays, who look nothing like the Yankees and, in fact, much better resemble the kind of rebels who took down the Death Star. They've got a lot to gain by beating the Yankees, more than the Red Sox do at this point, and act like it every time the two sides meet.
As Ric Flair said, to be the man you've got to beat the man. Tampa hasn't ever been the man in their own hometown. Because they train there, because Big Stein lives there and because New Yorkers relocate there, Tampa has always been considered Yankee territory. The Rays need to claim their home turf to carve out their own niche.
The Yankees, meanwhile, don't want to lose games to the team in their owner's backyard and don't want to fuel the rise of a new contender. When the first Yankee dynasty faded out in the 1960's, it was because they got too comfortable on top and didn't adapt to the game changing behind them. These Yankees have been more proactive but they've got to recognize a potential usurper and nip the challenge in the bud.
The Rays will never replace the Red Sox, no one could, but they could make it another 18 wrenching games a year with another opponent who hates them and everything they represent. And, after so many myopic years of Boston-New York, we'll be all the better for it.

















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-16-2008 @ 11:37AM
bet the super bowl said...
I'm sick of the Red sox. Bring on the Rays!
Reply
4-16-2008 @ 11:46AM
Jordi said...
Good points all. Except one problem: the Rays don't play in Tampa. The Yankees train in Tampa. The Rays play in St. Petersburg. And you also have to consider the Yankees a long time ago trained in St. Pete. So the Rays are battling history as well. But by the time the new park is built the Rays will be the team to beat in the AL East.
Reply
4-17-2008 @ 8:25AM
ken said...
JORDI
I HAVE TO AGREE WITH YOU IN A FEW YEARS THE RAYS WILL BE WINNING 90 PLUS GAMES A YEAR THEY MAY EVEN HIT 80 PLUS WINS THIS YEAR I LIVE HERE IN ST PETE NOW FROM BOSTON 10 YEARS NOW AND THEY HAVE SOME GREAT YOUNG PLAYERS
Reply
4-16-2008 @ 11:26PM
mannysea18 said...
Yankees/Red Sox Dead ? Are you for real ?
It is still the greatest and most heated rivalry in sports. Go to the Stadium or Fenway when ever they play and see for yourself.
Reply
4-18-2008 @ 7:14AM
Juan said...
Maybe someone can tell me if its true that the Yankee logo is placed at all the mens urinals at Fenway Park, if true, why at Yankee Stadium they don't use "red sox's" instead of toilet paper
Reply
4-20-2008 @ 4:51PM
joseph ullman said...
Oh man, am I ever tired of the "Yankee's Red Sox" rivalry. And I'm a lifelong Yankee fanatic who lives in Maine. Enough already, Bud! I don't want to see the Yankee's play 50% of their games against the AL East. I want to see Cleveland, White Sox, Seattle, interleague. I am so goddamn bored to tears with this whole thing. You're killing the golden goose. Let's face it; the Yankee's are "baseball" and win or lose they bring out the fans like no one else. So let 'em play more games against the AL West and Central. Bud - you listening?
Reply
4-20-2008 @ 12:54PM
Suzanne said...
I live in Oregon and it's always surprising to me how many Red Sox fan there are here. Last week alone I saw three people wearing Boston shirts or hats.
I notice them because my husband is from Weymouth, Mass. and I always stop and comment on their Boston hat or shirt. They are always fans. Always.
I'm of the opinion that often when one sees someone wearing Yankee apparel, it's often more of a fashion statement then a true fan. Likely because of hip hop fashion and videos made in NYC.
I stopped asking those people here where I live because after the third time I asked, I found out they weren't particularly Yankee fans.
This is the classic rivalry between David and Goliath, David being Boston and New York being Goliath, the giant from one of the biggest cities on the planet.
Besides, what's better then a rivalry that has lasted for a hundred years?
Reply