Maybe the All-Star Game is a meaningless to the players and just an excuse for Bud Selig to admire himself for a week. That doesn't mean that the selections should be stupid. Today, the MLB 'Haus gives you All-Star Grievances.Grievance: John Lackey deserved a spot. While the Angels pitching staff is very well represented with Francisco Rodriguez, Joe Saunders, and Ervin Santana all making the team, John Lackey is probably deserving of a spot as well. I know he missed about a quarter of the season thanks to an injury, but in the ten starts he has made since coming back, he's been damn near untouchable. His record is only 6-2, but his 1.96 ERA and WHIP of 0.92 are better than his three teammates that did make the squad.
Grievance: Ian Kinsler should be starting. While Ian Kinsler did make the All Star team, the fact he did so only as a reserve is insulting. While Boston fans stuffed the ballots for their man Dustin Pedroia (don't get me wrong, it's their right to do so) Kinsler was busy being the best second baseman in baseball. Pedroia deserves to be on the team, but he should be the man on the bench. He's hitting .313 with an OPS of .815 with nine homers and 41 RBI, but Ian checks in at .332 with an OPS of freaking .936 with 14 homers and 53 RBI. Tell me, who deserves the starting spot more?
Grievance: Ichiro making the team. Ichiro Suzuki is one of my favorite players in the game today, for reasons that have to do with his playing ability and the things he says, but he shouldn't be on the team this season. His starting spot should probably go to Jermaine Dye (who didn't make the team), Grady Sizemore, Carlos Quentin, J.D. Drew, or Milton Bradley. I know that each team has to have a representative, so Ichiro is Seattle's, but when a team has absolutely no chance of making the playoffs they really shouldn't have any say in who gets homefield advantage during the World Series.

















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
7-07-2008 @ 7:38AM
Wayne said...
Kinsler has like 16 errors. That's why Pedroia should start over him.
Reply
7-07-2008 @ 8:13AM
grapevinesooner said...
What Wayne said.
I'm a Rangers and Red Sox fan and while I think very highly of Kinsler, the one pock mark on his game is his errors. Granted, a number of the errors charged to him were on balls that many fielders wouldn't get to.
Reply
7-07-2008 @ 11:58AM
John Ankeney said...
The current selection process is a joke. Marginal players are selected by biased fans. To really make a valid all-star game select the pitchers with the lowest earned run averages. Select the other players by the highest battng averages and highest fielding averages. Average the two figures and select the two best players to each position. A long time ago only the best palyers participated in the All-Star game. Now anyone with a 200 plus average can be selected.
Reply