We still have more than seven months before the Baseball Writers' Association of America hands out its hardware, but why wait? MLB FanHouse's staff is ready to name the award winners today.But don't hold us to it.
These predictions are nothing more than having some fun. Think about it; there's two ways to predict who wins the MVP or Cy Young Award: take the obvious guy who's been at the top of his game (Johan Santana, Albert Pujols) or go with a hunch and make a stab at some so far unrewarded talent (Grady Sizemore, David Wright).
Our choices are below, and there's little consensus. Five different players got picked for AL MVP, five for AL Rookie of the Year, six for NL Cy Young, six for NL Rookie of the Year, seven for NL MVP and nine for AL Cy Young.
The most popular picks were for Florida's Cameron Maybin as NL Rookie of the Year and Grady Sizemore as AL MVP (both six panelists).
We must feel Cleveland will bounce back in the AL Central, since Sizemore was a popular choice for AL MVP. Sizemore is due some recognition; his 232 extra-base hits the past three seasons are most in the league.
Wright was the top pick in the NL, with teammate Jose Reyes getting one selection and division rival Chase Utley another. (I went off the board with Stephen Drew, just because.)
Most of our choices for AL Rookie of the Year will open the season in the minors, with Tampa Bay's David Price and Baltimore's Matt Wieters being picked by eight of the 13 panelists.
| Writer | AL MVP | NL MVP | AL Cy Young | NL Cy Young | AL Rookie of Year | NL Rookie of Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ed Price |
||||||
| Evan Longoria | Stephen Drew | Roy Halladay | Johan Santana | David Price |
Jordan Schafer | |
| Jeff Fletcher |
||||||
| Grady Sizemore | Hanley Ramirez | John Danks |
Brandon Webb | Brett Anderson | Cameron Maybin | |
| Jay Mariotti |
||||||
| Grady Sizemore | Ryan Howard | Daisuke Matsuzaka | Johan Santana | Matt Wieters | Cameron Maybin | |
| Dan Graziano |
||||||
| Kevin Youkilis | David Wright | Zack Greinke | Josh Johnson | Elvis Andrus | Colby Rasmus | |
| Andrew Johnson |
||||||
| Grady Sizemore | Albert Pujols | Roy Halladay | Tim Lincecum | Travis Snider | Colby Rasmus | |
| Matt Snyder |
||||||
| Grady Sizemore | David Wright | Felix Hernandez | Brandon Webb | Elvis Andrus | Jason Motte | |
| Will Brinson |
||||||
| Mark Teixeira | Chase Utley | Jake Peavy |
Cole Hamels | Matt Wieters | Tommy Hanson | |
| Pat Lackey |
||||||
| Kevin Youkilis | David Wright | Francisco Liriano | Johan Santana | Matt Wieters | Cameron Maybin | |
| Josh Alper |
||||||
| Mark Teixeira | Jose Reyes | Roy Halladay | Johan Santana | Matt Wieters | Cameron Maybin | |
| Tom Fornelli |
||||||
| Grady Sizemore | Albert Pujols | Josh Beckett | Johan Santana | David Price | Cameron Maybin | |
| Knox Bardeen |
||||||
| Justin Morneau | David Wright | Daisuke Matsuzaka | Dan Haren |
Travis Snider | Cameron Maybin | |
| Jon Bois |
||||||
| Carlos Quentin | Albert Pujols | Roy Halladay | Tim Lincecum | Matt Wieters | Tommy Hanson | |
| Jacob Wheatley-Schaller |
||||||
| Grady Sizemore | David Wright | CC Sabathia | Johan Santana | Matt Wieters | Colby Rasmus |
Editor's Note: Yes, we're aware Jake Peavy currently plays in the NL. Brinson's choice was intentional. Come back Friday for our playoff and World Series picks.



















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-02-2009 @ 2:54PM
tabbie78 said...
If you look at what has been going on this spring, I find it hard to believe that not one person picked Chris Carpenter as NL Cy Young. Yes, I know it is in question whether he can goa full season, but remember this, the last full season he pitched, he won the Cy Young. And his 1.52 ERA this spring is more representative of Carp. GO CARDS!
Reply
4-02-2009 @ 3:47PM
efogey said...
Jose Reyes isn't even the best shortstop in the national league east, let alone an mvp. He is a hotdog and there isn't enough mustard to cover him. He is self absorbed and immature and is more worried about how he looks then how he plays. he has a penchant for choking late in the season which is no accident. Sorry, Reyes is overrated and overpaid.
Reply
4-02-2009 @ 6:20PM
dickey523 said...
I think you need new experts because who the hell would pick josh johnson to win the nl cy young and greinke for al? What the hell were you thinking
Reply
4-02-2009 @ 7:03PM
Matt Snyder said...
Yeah, and who would have picked Cliff Lee for AL Cy Young last season?
4-03-2009 @ 8:53AM
Will said...
Peavy for the AL Cy Young is the best pick on the page.
Reply