Updated, 10:30 PM:BOSTON -- Manager Mike Scioscia strongly disputed umpire Rick Reed's description of Wednesday's postgame confrontation between the umpires and Angels coaches.
Told that Reed described Angels coaches as "unprofessional and unbecoming of a professional team," Scioscia said, "It was along the lines of, 'You've got to be kidding me.' I don't think there's any issue there at all.
"That's absolutely wrong. We had an emotional team. We respected their space. ... A lot of it was not even directed at them. It was guys venting.
"Yeah, there's some profanity. You know what? In an emotional game like that, there's going to be some venting that's going to be done."
Reed implied some Angels coaches might be suspended by Major League Baseball. Said Scioscia, "We've talked to the league, too."
Scioscia even fired back at umpire Mark Wegner, whom he said "came back [up the tunnel] to confront one of our coaches. If anything, a little lesson in professionalism for Mark Wegner needs to be discussed."
Reed said Scioscia "made an attempt to quiet his coaches down. He also made a comment that I thought incited the situation."
Responded Scioscia: "I made a quiet comment to Rick Reed, and that's between me and him."
Original story:
After a few calls went against them in Wednesday's 9-8 loss to the Red Sox, especially a ball four to pinch hitter Nick Green that forced in a run, the Angels had some strong quotes about the umpiring.
But what will get them in trouble is what they said on the field.
Fenway Park is one of the few stadiums where the umpiring crew has to leave the field through a dugout, in this case the visitors'. And Angels coaches Alfredo Griffin and Mike Butcher seemed to confront the umpires immediately after Wednesday's game ended.
"Their deportment leaving the field, going through the Angels dugout, left a lot to be desired," Rick Reed, the home-plate umpire Wednesday, said before Thursday's game. "I was disappointed in the coaches. Coaches are usually the guys who try and stop any kind of friction that develops in the course of a game. But they were initiating it last night. I'm not pleased with the way they said things or their presentation. Major League Baseball has been notified, and probably something will come of it.
"I would think there would be a coach or two regretting their actions today."
Without naming the coaches in question, Reed called them "unprofessional and unbecoming of a professional team."
Reed said Angels manager Mike Scioscia "made an attempt to quiet his coaches down. He also made a comment that I thought incited the situation."
In his media session after the game, Scioscia said, "I was surprised. It's a good umpiring crew. We really feel strongly they missed a couple of times. ... What was the count at the end, three-and-four to Green?"
Closer Brian Fuentes, who threw the pitch to Green, intimated that the umpires were intimidated by the Fenway crowd.
"It's a big pitch, a huge pitch," Fuentes said after the game. "I'm buckling down. The hitter's buckling down. [Reed] needs to do the same."
Having looked at replays, Reed said the final pitch to Green was "borderline" and that he called it a ball partly because catcher Mike Napoli brought up the ball after catching it.
"It very well could have been a strike," said Reed, in his 28th season as a big-league umpire. "It was a pitch that was at the bottom of the strike zone."

















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
9-17-2009 @ 6:33PM
sdh4194 said...
the umpire (reed) blew the call.
Reply
9-18-2009 @ 1:51PM
wakko66 said...
Umpires who are making wrong calls more than ever are calling managers & players unprofessional? What a joke. The lack of good officiating in all sports is what is really unprofessional. I wish I got paid a lot of money to be a part of sports, then make calls any way I felt like it & not only keep my job but be above criticism. From allowing a batter to walk on a 3-4 count (yes, that is written correctly) to telling a player he didn't need to be tagged to be out at third even tho there was no force play (which is what one of these "professionals" told Derek Jeter), umpiring is at an all-time low. Either retrain these morons or get replacements who actually care about doing their job properly. Mistakes are one thing, everyone is human, but when the same individuals make bad calls over & over with no disciplinary action taken against them, what's the incentive to make sure they get it right?
9-17-2009 @ 6:45PM
ed344mu said...
When do the umpires ever take responsibility for really bad calls? The answer is never! This woodchuck should shut-up and not call out any player or coach because they seem to answer to no one when they change a game!
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 6:51PM
erp880 said...
i would be "unprofessional" too if umpires blew 3 calls that cost me a game too. what a joke this umpire is.
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 6:58PM
Ali said...
The umpire said that it might have been a strike,a borderline call that could have gone either way, but part of the reason it was called a ball was because Napoli framed it and brought it up. He obviously thought it was a bit low too, or why would he have framed it? I thought the umpires explained themselves quite well. Sour grapes won't change the outcome.
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 8:49PM
gjones1052 said...
As an umpire I don't give a rats rear end where or who is playing. I make my calls based on the pitch, not who the batter is and their rep or the fans or anything else. Fact is Reed blew both calls, knows it and deserved to get an earful from the Angels. If it were April or May it might be a little different but this is September and the umps should be at thir peak performance. No excuses.
9-18-2009 @ 1:04PM
defuivxx said...
you always frame the pitch as a catcher. If the umpire wasn't looking at the pitch he sees the glove in the strike zone."It very well could have been a strike," said Reed, in his 28th season as a big-league umpire. "It was a pitch that was at the bottom of the strike zone." He even says it was the bottom of the strike zone still the strike zone. Play should determine the winner not the officials
9-17-2009 @ 7:02PM
The Elkester said...
Why didn't the HP ump ask for HELP On the Check Swing, And neither did the Catcher or Pitcher, blown calls are part of the game , But lately some Ump's are out of control
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 7:03PM
Angel said...
Not only was a it a bad call on the 3-2 pitch but they missed the check swing too. Bad Call but today is another game.
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 7:14PM
ed344mu said...
With apologies to Mike Vick, I didn't have a dog in the fight. I was just commenting on my years of being a baseball fan and thought the ump's comments were lame. We've all seen egregiously bad calls ignored by the umpiring crew after a game, so I give them little support when they try to blame a player or coach for being too outspoken!
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 7:20PM
BrianC6234 said...
Ricky Reed is is disappointed in the Angel coaches? What? That moron cost us a big win. He should be fired and put in front of a firing squad. At least fired. Congress should investigate the prick for being on the take.
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 8:23PM
FUZZY said...
CONGRESS SHOULD INVESIGATE? ARE YOU OUT OF YOUR MIND GIMME A FIN BREAK. ITS PART OF THE GAME ,BLOWN CALLS ENUFF SAID
9-17-2009 @ 7:23PM
BrianC6234 said...
"I thought the umpires explained themselves quite well. Sour grapes won't change the outcome. "
I guess we all know Ricky Reed's screen name now.
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 7:47PM
Ali said...
That was funny....I laughed!
9-17-2009 @ 7:44PM
whm2400 said...
Yesterday it might have been a strike, tommorrow it might be a strike, but today, its a ball!
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 7:47PM
arkmanmat said...
What a bunch of babies the Angels are. They are good wt winning during the season, but suck at winning in the post season....and that means falling to the RED SOX...GO SOX !!!!
Reply
9-18-2009 @ 2:15PM
rileyintarpon said...
Talk about failing in post season. You got to get there first. How many years did your "beloved" not get there in the past 40 years?
9-17-2009 @ 8:18PM
tbrown5373 said...
Horrible call! That's why MLB needs to set up and electronic balls and strike machine with lasers to call pitches. One umpires zone is low the other is high, enough! It can be done with eletronics let's cut the bull and just do it...Who needs some guy sitting back there call pitches any way!!! Ediots!!!!
Reply
9-17-2009 @ 8:56PM
gjones1052 said...
By babies do you mean like the Sox for, what, 80 some years not winning a World Series and blaming it on the curse of The Bambino? Talk about a "homer".
Reply
9-18-2009 @ 1:21PM
gtxtra84 said...
Curse of the Bambino? LOL...thats all of the Yankees doing. They created that to taunt the Red Sox. Then the Yankees did the biggest choke in baseball history and we never hear of that any more. But my Cubbies need to win it all!