In Advanced Scouting, MLB FanHouse's professional talent evaluator breaks down each of the playoff teams from a scouting perspective.Despite their great number of strengths, no team is without their holes and the Yankees are no different. The Yankees have tightened up their defense in the last year to match up more favorably against fundamentals-oriented teams like the Angels, but that has not changed the pace they like to play at. Pace is not an often discussed factor in baseball, but a team like the Yankees thrives on controlling the pace of the action and using its steady, methodical approach to win ballgames.
While their potent offense may typically be the reason for their long games, it is the rhythm of the Yankee starting staff that will need to be disrupted. If pitchers of the caliber of CC Sabathia, A.J. Burnett and Andy Pettitte are given breathing room, they will only be more difficult to handle.
Rhythm and pace are one set of things, but how do you stop the New York lineup? The Yankees offer up a unique dilemma for opposing pitchers. If you nibble and stay away, they will sit, wait and wear down your staff until they can blow the game open. But, with a lineup full of explosive bats to face, pounding the zone with fastballs could also lead to an early night in the showers for any pitcher. What it will take is a pitcher who can throw strikes with his secondary pitches early in the count and can pitch backwards when necessary.
Some of the pitchers to have success against New York's lineup in the last two months include John Danks, Brett Tomko, Junichi Tazawa, Roy Halladay, Felix Hernandez, Joe Saunders, and Paul Byrd. What do most of these individuals have in common? They were able to establish a well-spotted secondary pitch early in the count and throw consistent strikes. This is obviously a successful strategy against any club, but it is a near necessity to survive against the Yankees.
Matchups To Watch
As touched on earlier, the pitchers that have slowed the Yankee bats of late seem to have one particular thing in common. They were able to pitch backwards, and fall into no particular pattern early in the count. As electrifying as they can be, it will be fascinating to see fastball-happy hurlers Justin Verlander and Edwin Jackson lock horns with the Yankees if the Tigers can beat out the Twins in the one-game playoff Tuesday. They use their fastballs liberally, to say the least, and for good reason, but it has typically been the pitchers with an unpredictable pitch mix that have given the Yankees their problems.
X-Factors
Alfredo Aceves: Especially if the Yankees advance beyond the first round, a game will likely arise where Aceves will become pivotal to a Yankee victory. Aceves can thrive against lefties and righties, and give New York innings out of the pen they may desperately need. A valuable bullpen arm, Aceves may still be flying under the radar, but his 91-93 mph moving fastball coupled with three quality secondary pitches give the Yankees an arm with starter stuff working out of a variety of roles in the 'pen. • Scouting Perspective: You'll know early in the outing if Aceves is on. He likes to mix his pitches right out of the gate, and if he's spotting his 12-6 curveball, he likely has that good feel for his pitches right away. His stuff is underrated, but he has an uncanny sense for reading bats and staying out of patterns.
Melky Cabrera: Within a galaxy of superstars, there is Cabrera somewhere near the bottom of not just the lineup, but also the priority list when teams prepare to face the Yankees. But there is one simple fact that cannot be overlooked about him: Melky Cabrera hits good pitching. His slashing style is not always pleasing to the eye, but the way he lets the ball track deep in the zone translates well against pitchers with late action and lively stuff. He's developed into a far more patient hitter this year and is slowly learning to pick his spots to drive the ball and hit more off his back leg. Look for Cabrera to play a potentially big offensive role in the playoffs. His compact, contact-conscious swing plays well in a playoff atmosphere where the home run ball can become scarce. • Scouting Perspective: Cabrera's holes seemed to have filled up in a hurry in 2009. Once susceptible to the breaking ball down and in as a left-handed hitter, he now drives the pitch and has forced pitchers to respect him on the inner half and pitch more to his strengths on the outer half of the plate. Your best bet to put him away is still up and in, and his possible first-round matchup against the Tigers' Justin Verlander and Edwin Jackson could be a big test. Make no mistake, this is a fundamentally improved hitter, who, while not a potent threat, can handle pitches in all four quadrants of the zone and adjust to changing speeds.
Joba Chamberlain: No breakdown of the New York Yankees can be complete without a look at Chamberlain. So, why might Joba end up being so significant for New York being that he may not even be part of the rotation? In his latest and first relief outing this season, the fastball velocity and the bite on the slider was on the rise. Running the fastball up to 96 mph and bringing the slider at 87-89, it will be fascinating to see how his stuff translate as he moves back into one-inning stints. Assuming they elect to slide Chamberlain back in to a bullpen role in the first round, his stuff may be peaking at the right time, and we may see the dominant version of Joba we saw in 2007. • Scouting Perspective: Joba's keys to success are rather uncomplicated. Many point to his issues of tempo and that is valid, but he has had battles with his delivery as well. He has struggled on and off to iron out a pause in his it, and he needs to continue to be aggressive with his finish over his front leg to generate his velocity and tight slider spin. Keep an eye on the finish in Chamberlain's delivery; if he's getting his front leg over early, you'll see that good velocity that has come and gone this year, and more importantly, he'll be able to get his fastball to the inside corner to lefties without it leaking back over the plate.
David Robertson: There may be no bigger X-factor to the Yankees' post-season success than Robertson. He fills a key role in the seventh inning that few teams can fill. In the playoffs, where deep counts and high pitch counts become even more a part of the game, he becomes a dangerous weapon. • Scouting Perspective: Out of college, Robertson was known for his power arm and strikeout stuff, and despite minor-league success, some Yankee fans wondered where his power stuff had gone. Whatever the case may have been, Robertson has seen his velocity spike in recent months, often up to 95 mph. His newfound velocity, and plus, late-breaking, overhand curveball have made him one of the toughest pitchers to put bat on ball against in the American League. Keep an eye on Robertson's silky smooth delivery; it is that methodical delivery and outstanding extension on his finish toward the plate that make his 91-95 mph play like an upper-90s fastball.
Frankie Piliere spent the last three seasons working as a scout, most recently in the professional scouting department for the Texas Rangers in 2009. He now serves as the National Baseball Analyst here at FanHouse.

















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
10-06-2009 @ 5:49AM
Lowell said...
You forgot to mention they will be putting not 1, but 2 speedsters on the base paths for this post season roster since they only need 3 starters, they are going with just 10 pitchers. That translates to a much deeper bench with an added threat the Yankees have not had in the post season in many years!
Reply
10-05-2009 @ 7:11AM
Mark said...
Being a Red Sox fan I obviously know alittle bit about what the Yanks are doing. Part of the reason I think the Yankees are more solid this year is they seems to be having more fun. In the past they have been too serious,worrying about their image but they are much looser and enjoying the game. They are going to be tough and the playoffs should be great.
Reply
10-05-2009 @ 10:00AM
andrew3523 said...
lets face it, everyone wants the yankees and red sox for the final go at the world series. i've been a yankee fan since 1952 and wouldn't want it any other way. can't imagine minnesota and st. louis in the world series lol. take the red sox and yankees out of it and the ratings will be lower than leno at this point
Reply
10-05-2009 @ 10:57AM
tonytiger18 said...
The key in a short series is pitching. There is very little room for error.
The role players can play an integral part if the pitching does what is expected.
But, CC, AJ and Pettite must hold down the fort which is basicly pitch into the sixth or seventh and keep the opposition below three runs.
The other ingredient is Gerardi. He has improved and learned from his past decisions. He uses his bench well and mixs and matches his pitchers in the right situation.
The Yankees will hit enough if the pitching stays on course. That is the real key.
I do like their chances and their mentality.
Reply
10-05-2009 @ 12:14PM
Mark said...
"The role players can play an integral part if the pitching does what is expected.
But, CC, AJ and Pettite must hold down the fort which is basicly pitch into the sixth or seventh and keep the opposition below three runs."
Exactly. Being a Sox fan I hated Scott Brosius (Well not really) but it always seemed like he hurt us and while he's no where near as talented as A-rod , he's got something Alex dont and that's world series rings. Go back to 2004 , yes Ortiz and Ramirez were huge but without Bill Mueller , Dave Roberts , Doug M , and Orlando Cabrera we probably dont win.
10-05-2009 @ 12:37PM
sphinxter said...
I personally disagree with the sentiment that everyone wants the Yankees and the Red Sox in the ALCS. As a non-Yankee and non-Red Sox fan, I want anything, but those two teams in the ALCS. No offense, but the only people who want those two teams in the ALCS are Boston and New York fans along with Bud Selig.
However, I'll admit that other than rooting for the Angels to win, just because of Adenhart, the most "pleasure" I'll get in this postseason is rooting against the Red Sox and Yankees. It's a little hard to do that if neither makes the World Series.
Reply
10-05-2009 @ 1:05PM
Matt Snyder said...
You don't speak for everybody either. I'm a Cubs fan living in Indianapolis and I have no tie to MLB.
I desperately want a Yankees/Red Sox ALCS.
10-05-2009 @ 6:06PM
tonytiger18 said...
Sphinx is very similiar to one of my friends.
We go to Atlantic City on occasion with a group of friends.
This friend of mine doesn't care if he wins, as long as everyone else loses.
He also gets pleasure of seeing everyone else lose more than he did.In short, he is one very unhappy and insecure person.
I hope that when you root against the Yankees and/or the Red Sox that you get your rocks off.
For you are truly an unhappy fan of your losing team that probably won't make the playoffs for another thirty years.
10-05-2009 @ 1:23PM
sphinxter said...
Apparently, you can't reply to your own comment...Fair enough.
Anyway, that's fair enough. I suppose I feel into the same argument that I pointed out. I should have said most just like he should have.
However, I doubt anyone other than their fans want to see either team win it all. I could be wrong, but I can't imagine a fan of another team openly wanting the Yankees to get number twenty-seven or the Sox to win their third this decade. Especially when their own team hasn't won one in over a century. Again, I obviously don't know exactly what you think, but I at least know that none of the Cubs fans I know want either team to even be in the ALCS, much less win it all.
Reply
10-09-2009 @ 11:13PM
waaaaazuuuuup said...
i dont think that comment was saying that everyone wants to see nyy abd the redsox in the finale game.. i think what he ment was if your team doesent make the playoffs wich 2 teams would be a good ws battle to watch.. the biggest and most view rilvery in mlb is the redsox vrs yankees.. of course if you a twins fan and your team is still in it you not going to want to see the sox and the yanks play eachother in the finale
10-05-2009 @ 1:57PM
Mark said...
Well of course MLB wants a Sox-Yankees series but the fans have no one to blame but themselves for that. Look what the ratings are when those teams arent involved . People complain about the Yanks and the Sox but look at the stadiums and tv....Certainly the Cubs would draw huge ratings if they ever make it. Could you imagine the media hype and ratings if it had been Cubs -Sox in 2003 or 2004?. I'd bet money MLB wanted that
Reply
10-06-2009 @ 8:35AM
bobanthonyvideo said...
Pace is the Yankees weakness? If that's all he could find-bring on the rings....
Reply
10-06-2009 @ 10:13AM
Tracey Lea said...
they are tougher this year more a team great off season acquistions and finally realized to go younger not just star names no more Randy Johnson David Wells Clemens or the Moose and a democrat in the White House look more balanced to win it this year we'll see if CC pitches well against the Sox or Burnett steps up at all or middle relief holds but they are the deserved favorites
Reply
10-06-2009 @ 12:04PM
Weedman said...
The Yankees went out and spent all that money for this exact reason. They expect those guys to step up to the plate and continue to pitch the way they have all year. The AL is obviously tough this year especially with the Angels and Red Sox but i guarantee anything less of a World Series is not acceptable to anyone in the Yankees organization.
Reply
10-06-2009 @ 12:15PM
Edwin said...
hands down Yanks are the team to beat!!!!
Reply
10-06-2009 @ 12:24PM
natalecass said...
Did anyone happen to notice that the curse of the babe was lifted after the yanks go A-Rod? Since we've gotten him, we've done nothing in the play-offs. Sometimes I wonder if we would have been better off without him.As a die hard Yankee fan I really want a Yankee Boston show down so we can send them bums back to boston and once again be the Beast from the east.
Reply
10-06-2009 @ 4:05PM
John Arnold said...
Isn't it strange that as soon as a player dons a Yankee uniform he becomes obnoxious?
Reply
10-09-2009 @ 11:16PM
waaaaazuuuuup said...
what is more stranger is when the yankees are on top the redsox fans get more obnoxious...
Reply