Prospects exist to help their team fortify their future, be it years down the road, or, in some cases, the not-so-distant future. These prospects can become valuable chips in blockbuster trades. Each team with a player on the block this offseason will come to the negotiating table with stacks of detailed scouting information on the prospects of buyers out there like the New York Yankees. So, what should teams like the Blue Jays, Tigers or any other club rumored to be in talks with the Yankees be looking to get in return? We'll take a look from a scouting perspective at just what potential trade partners should be looking for as they sift through the crop of New York prospects, with a focus on some who may be flying under the radar.
The Untouchables
Jesus Montero, C -- Some scouts make the argument that Montero is the best hitting prospect in the minor leagues. That's debatable, but at the catching position, which I believe he can stick at, few players are as valuable. You just don't find too many bats as potent as his behind the dish. He's shown offensive skills reminiscent of Miguel Cabrera on his way up. It would likely take a blockbuster-type deal to pry him away but this is the guy you want for your team if you are dealing a star to New York.
Austin Jackson, OF -- Given his rather quick growth as an all-around star prospect, it's easy to forget that many worried coming out of the draft that Jackson was a raw athlete and wouldn't develop as a complete ballplayer. It's been his ability to hit consistent line drives and keep his swing under control at such an early stage that makes him special. The athletic tools, plus speed and defense in center field were more of a given. The fact that he is still continuing to grow as a hitter is what makes him such an interesting commodity.
High-Risk Talents
Andrew Brackman, RHP -- At this time last year it wouldn't have been unreasonable to believe that Brackman, pictured right, would be among potential untouchables, but as 2009 unfolded it was clear that he would face all the roadblocks that a near 7-foot pitcher coming off arm surgery could. To say he struggled mightily with his command is an understatement as his walk totals were off the charts. What was more concerning, however, was the fluctuation in his raw stuff. While reports were more positive when he worked as a reliever later in the year, there were times when his stuff was close to pedestrian.
Sleepers
Manny Banuelos, LHP -- You could make the argument that Banuelos doesn't completely qualify as a sleeper, but it's about time the baseball world was fully aware just how talented this 18-year-old lefty actually is. He doesn't have the size at 5-foot-10 and he doesn't throw 97 mph, but the total package and maturity is something to behold. Sitting at 90-92 mph, reaching 94 mph at times, Banuelos works through a lineup with very little effort. And, with some further physical maturity, it's not unreasonable to think he could pick up a little more velocity.
Despite his good lively fastball from the left side, that's not what makes him so intriguing. It is his pitching aptitude and uncanny feel for the game. He is the owner of two above-average secondary pitches, the changeup and the curveball. There's a debate among scouts as to which is a better offering. He appeared to be more consistently comfortable with the changeup at 76-80 mph, but he also showed command for the 11-5 breaking ball at 72-74 mph.
The stuff is above average, but when you consider the advanced feel he has for pitching and the often pinpoint command he possesses it's amazing that he's still only 18. He pitches with such ease and attacks hitters with such a calm demeanor, that he can be a front-of-the-rotation pitcher in the majors a few years from now. If you're trading with New York and looking for its most complete pitching prospect, look no further than Banuelos.
Hector Noesi, RHP -- He does not have the gifts or feel for pitching that Banuelos has, but that is certainly no insult. Noesi is the type of prospect that shows up in deals quite frequently. He's a little older than you'd like for a pitcher below Double-A, but has the stuff of a No. 3 big-league starter. Another reason you may not know much about Noesi is because in 2008 he was much shorter in his arsenal than he is today.
When I had the chance to see him then, he was pitcher severely lacking in secondary pitches despite his good velocity and fastball command. This year was a much different story. He displayed downright dominance at times, especially in his stint with at low Single-A Charleston (S.C.). Maybe most impressive of all was his stamina; his stuff would sometimes improve as his pitch count mounted. Although he still likes to mostly to work of his well spotted 90-94 mph fastball, this year there was the curveball as well. With good 12-6 action, the curveball came out whenever Noesi seemed to need it this year. He had a feel for just how much to mix it in and varied the speeds from 72-76 mph. With a second pitch that now shows flashes of being plus, and an occasional changeup mixed in, Noesi showed tremendous growth in 2009 and became a complete pitcher. He could be a guy that continues to emerge in a hurry and may not be far off from the big leagues. Of course, this is just a glimpse of a number of valuable prospects the Yankees have to offer if they want to net a coveted player in a trade. New York has developed a very deep system, and has situated itself to pull off a blockbuster trade. Whether it's Curtis Granderson or Roy Halladay or someone else, the Yankees can entice the owners of these stars with the strong crop of prospects they have to offer. Whether they do so remains to be seen, but having the ability to pull off such a deal off is clearly not a concern.
Frankie Piliere spent the last three seasons working as a scout, most recently in the professional scouting department for the Texas Rangers in 2009. He now serves as the National Baseball Analyst here at FanHouse.



















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
11-13-2009 @ 8:41AM
coneyloveme said...
yankees were smarting to keep young players and use most of veterans player !! cut down with money ! the yankees will get back to the playoff in 2010
Reply
11-13-2009 @ 9:06AM
ftheyanks said...
All the yankless needs to do is give up about 50 mill.to blue jays and they can get roy halloday and keep thier prospects.Thier is no reason to give anything up.Infact that pig running the store bought champs can get any player in league with all the greed these owners have.once again salary cap. ftheyanks
Reply
11-14-2009 @ 11:13AM
broinvt said...
brillant
11-14-2009 @ 11:53AM
tcaminito said...
you are a jealous a-hole
11-13-2009 @ 10:11AM
chucka2552 said...
I think this is the first person I have heard, including Brian Cashman, who thinks Montero can stick at catcher
Reply
11-13-2009 @ 2:08PM
Bob Knob said...
How about a "Salary Ceiling" ???
Then your stupid-pig owner will have to invest in his (your) team - instead of his personal bank account....your owners are your problem - not the Yankees Organization.
Reply
11-13-2009 @ 2:30PM
Bob Knob said...
..."Salary Floor" - meaning a minimum level each team MUST pay in salaries.
No Luxury Tax "welfare / hand-outs" to be included....hell. no Luxury Tax at all !
....not Salary Ceiling (MB)
Reply
11-13-2009 @ 3:14PM
ftheyanks said...
Bob yankless agonization really have been a MLB problem sence thier first world series win.when they stole Babe Ruth from Boston for 135,000 so that owner could put on a broad way show.until thier last paying 423.5 million on free agents.infact when I really think about it did they ever win without paying for it?NY fans are use to buying Championships.BY now they believe its ok.And they have earned it.What about integrity and honor thats something Stienbrenner and his fan base will never have.Stop the madness salary cap. ftheyanks
Reply
11-13-2009 @ 6:59PM
psu74dl said...
anyone who wants a salery cap is a socialist!!!
11-13-2009 @ 8:29PM
Ralph Garcia said...
Would you like it if everyone in the US had to work for minimum wage including you? NO, if you like it then move to another country. The reason the Yankees can spend this kind of money is that they go to see games in great numbers whether win or lose. Now there are teams that fans don't go to see games like the Florida Marlins. They're like communist as they want the wealth to be distributed equally. Look at all the sea of empty seats on ESPN highlights when someone hits a home run at Landshark Stadium. This was even years before the recession hit. Yankee haters complain that they have no farm system. Look at all the prospects they have. When the Yankees don't win that year, the Yankee haters rub it in saying I hope you go broke. You also say the Yankees suck, yeah they suck ALL THE LIFE OUT OF YOUR TEAM'S CHAMPIONSHIP HOPES!!!If you compare the Yankees to the country, the Yankees are like America. Half the world hates us, the other half envies us. The Red Sox and the Dallas Cowboys are like France. The Red Sox fans are also known as the big bRAG machine. They're arrogant, brag a lot and are not humble. On second thought, they're like a terrorist country. That is the truth, mr. sour grapes. Would you like some cheese with that whine?
11-13-2009 @ 4:54PM
Zak said...
The Yankees have such a deep system, its crazy to think you didn't touch on STUDs like Arodys Vizcaino, Slade Heathcott, Jose Ramirez and Austime Romine to name a few.
Reply
11-13-2009 @ 8:30PM
jmaneuv011 said...
If there's one thing the Yankees have done well over the years it's knowing what prospects to hold on to. The only good player I can think of they moved was Mike Lowell, but then again they were never really lacking at 3B recently anyway (especially having ARod now)
Reply
11-13-2009 @ 10:58PM
ftheyanks said...
Ralph your a moron first of all I'm a phillies fan yes we have gone through alot of bad years.Are owners are notoriusly money hungry pigs.like stienbrenner.why do the think are team broke a record for most loses of any franchise of any sport last year over 10,000.loses.and all of a sudden we have a good team wow thats great.win a world series wonderfull. Along comes that pig stienbrenner spending 423.5 million dollars on free agents to buy number 27 ya I quess that would make you a little bitter.Then I start to investigate I find out how the yankless do it everytime they PAY PAY PAY and win what a joke. Right from the start thier is absolutely no question we need a salary cap both top and bottom.Stop the madness and keep any integrity left in MLB alive.ftheyanks
Reply
11-14-2009 @ 12:15AM
THOMAS M. HILL said...
you sound bitter to me!!!!
11-14-2009 @ 7:27AM
Ralph Garcia said...
If I ever see you at a Yankee game and you've got that on the back of your jersey, you'll really find out how tough New Yorkers are. I don't need help from any other Yankee fan. I'll take you on myself, first of all for calling me a moron. By the way, you'll probably never even show up for a game even at your own stadium. Yeah there are a lot of crybabies crying sour grapes but your team can't afford the players because you don't show up to your own favorite team's home game. Now where would you like to meet as I plan to sweep the floor with you.
11-13-2009 @ 11:00PM
jmaneuv011 said...
I hate to say this as a union guy, but what MLB needs is non-guaranteed contracts. Compare the quality of the NFL now (non guaranteed contracts with salary cap) vs. the quality of the NBA (guaranteed contracts with salary cap). The NFL has gotten much better and the NBA has turned into crap!
I think the soft cap system in Baseball is fine. If it's worth it for the Yankees to pay a luxury tax every season then go for it! The other teams profit from that anyway.
Reply
11-13-2009 @ 11:25PM
ftheyanks said...
love the idea,but the players agents will never go for it.alone with salary cap perfect Idea.ftheyanks
Reply
11-14-2009 @ 3:26AM
tom rules said...
who cares about what the yanks paid. oh yeah its the only excuse the losers can come up with. i think the yanks are gonna get halladay this year and really do some damage. dang joe might have to get number 29 next year. the new stadium looks great by the way.
Reply
11-14-2009 @ 11:17AM
broinvt said...
pay pay pay? Please take this time to explain why they havent won the 8 previous seasons when they paid paid paid? You're truly a person you like to hear himself talk/
Reply
11-14-2009 @ 12:57PM
redliwcor said...
To all of you who are crying about the Yanks, may I lick your tears?
Reply